The firm above you simply has more reviews
When five firms sit within a mile of the same courthouse, proximity stops separating them. Review count, recency and reply rate do. That is a solvable problem and most firms never work it.
Marietta firms compete on a different axis to Atlanta ones. The Cobb County courthouse sits two blocks off the Square and so do half the firms in the county, which means your competition is not a television advertiser — it is the practice four doors down with three hundred more Google reviews than you.
1
County that decides your rankings
3
Map pack results above everything else
90
Days to visible movement

In a single-county market the ranking factors compress. Proximity is roughly equal between competitors clustered around the same courthouse, so the tie is broken somewhere else.
When five firms sit within a mile of the same courthouse, proximity stops separating them. Review count, recency and reply rate do. That is a solvable problem and most firms never work it.
A profile that lists an Atlanta mailing address while the office is on Roswell Street confuses the one signal that matters most in a county-sized market.
A single "practice areas" page cannot rank for family law, criminal defense and probate at once. Cobb searches are specific and reward pages that are equally specific.
Most Marietta inquiries arrive as calls, not forms. Without call tracking every one of them is attributed to nothing and the budget gets set by guesswork.